PiCloud followup… bumpy road

12 Mar 2010 #data #picloud #python

I had to crunch some data today, and decided to experiment a bit. It mostly involved lots and lots of Levenshtein ratios. On my laptop it took over 25 minutes to complete a single run (45k rows, several thousand calculations per row) – a bummer when you want to quickly iterate the rules, cutoffs, penalties, etc. First step was simply cutting out some work that was a nice-to-have. That got me down to 16 minutes.

Second was adding multiprocessing. I figured this would be easy, but the way I originally wrote the code (the function required both an element, and a penalty matrix) meant that just plain multiprocessing.Pool.map() wasn’t working. I wrapped it up with itertools.izip(iterator, itertools.repeat(matrix)), but that gives a tuple which you can’t easily export. It turns out that this, basically calculatorstar from the Pool example, is a godsend:

def wrapper(args):
    return func(*args)

So that got me down to 8 minutes on my laptop. However the cool part is that on an 8 core server I was down to only 1 minute, 30 seconds. Those are the sorts of iteration times I can deal with.

Then I decided to try the PiCloud. After trying it out earlier this week I thought it would be interesting to test it on a real problem that linearly scales with more cores.  They advertise it in the docs, so I figured maybe it would be useful and even faster. Not so fast. It was easy to write after I already had multiprocessing working, but the first version literally crashed my laptop. I later figured out that the “naive” way to write it made it suck up all the RAM on the system. After less than 5 minutes I killed it with 1.7GB/2GB consumed. Running it on the aforementioned 8 core/32GB server had it consume 5GB before it finally crashed with a HTTP 500 error. I posted in the forums, got some advice, but still can’t get it working. (Read that short thread for the rest of the story). This seems like exactly what they should be nailing, but so far they’re coming up empty.